Beef Wrap March 12
Yet another week with the cash cattle market stuck at $114. Thatfs six weeks in a row for anyone who is counting. The cutouts continued to fall this week, with the Choice down over $6 and the Select down close to $3. Packer margins moved lower, now at gonlyh $329/hd. The decline in the cutouts is not unexpected, but there is some disagreement about how long the cutouts will trend lower. Some think the Choice has risk back down to $210-215, but I donft see it sliding much beyond $220. Ifd look for the cutouts to bottom and turn higher before March is done. The daily demand scatters have clearly indicated that beef demand is slipping lower and we see the same thing in the combined margin chart below. This has not been a very steep drop in the combined margin and that, I think, is an indication that demand is going to find its legs quicker this time around. Of course being on the cusp of spring also is a positive for beef demand. International demand for US beef is good, but not great. We got the January export numbers from USDA this week and it showed exports almost unchanged from a year ago, but down 40 million pounds from the December total. On the supply side, it looks like this weekfs fed kill will come in around 510k, which is a bit less than I had hoped for, but still strong enough to clear out a few more backlogged cattle from the February winter storm. Cattle feeders are anxiously watching the weather maps again because there is a big storm forecast to move into Colorado and W. Nebraska this weekend. It will dump a lot of snow in the Rockies, but fortunately there are not a lot of cattle up at those elevations. There might be enough snow to snarl operations at JBSfs plant in Greeley on Monday, but other than that, it doesn’t look to me like this weather system is going to be anywhere near as bad as the mid-February weather event. As the system moves eastward, it will drop rain rather than snow and that could make feedyards in Nebraska and Iowa more muddy than they already are. Cattle performance could take a modest hit. Speaking of cattle performance, USDA reported steer carcass weights down another 10 pounds this week. That comes on the heels of a 10 pound drop the previous week and highlights just how detrimental the February weather event was to cattle weight gains. Steer weights are now one pound below last year. Finally, it appears as though carcass weights have normalized almost one year after the pandemic broke onto the scene and roiled the livestock markets. That should greatly help to move the leverage meter back in the cattle feederfs favor and makes me pretty confident that the next move in the cash market will be higher. It is just a matter of when that will happen. Futures traders appear to be ready to acknowledge that the rally in cash cattle and beef prices might take a little longer to get going than originally envisioned. This was evidenced by a significant reduction in the spread between the Apr and Jun contracts. In fact, by the end of the week that spread had moved almost $2.50 lower and as of the close Friday the June contract was carrying a $1.42 premium to the April. It is a very unusual occurrence for June to trade over April. My fundamental work suggests that the highest cattle and beef prices are likely to occur in May. I also think that the longer it takes to get the cash market rally going, the smaller the rally will be. Packers can see the hole in cattle supplies coming just like the rest of us. It has been well advertised and they have had plenty of time to prepare for it. Markets normally run faster and further when there is an element of surprise involved. Recall the old trader adage: gwell anticipated markets never happen.h Now, Ifm not ready to say that the spring rally wonft happen, but it is so well anticipated that packers will use a number of techniques (like trying to increase the number of contracted cattle) to mitigate the financial impact on their operations. Obviously when packers are caught by surprise they donft have those techniques in place and thus prices run higher and faster than they would otherwise. So the longer cash stays stuck here at $114, the less bullish cattle I become. Theoretically, the same thing could happen in the beef market. If buyers have been anticipating a tight supply situation for spring, they will take actions to try and reduce the impact on their operations (ie, forward pricing, building freezer stocks, etc). In general though, it seems that packers are much better in tune with these upcoming events than beef buyers are. So we could end up with a situation this spring where the beef market soars and the cattle market gains are unimpressive. That would be a windfall for packers, but by now they have grown accustomed to huge margins. Next week watch the progression of the winter storm, particularly snow accumulations in Nebraska and Western Colorado. If the storm is broader than advertised, it might work to reduce carcass weights further. Watch for downtime from the Greeley plant also.